WFLA News Channel 8 The Tampa Tribune CentroTampa.com

TBO.com - Tampa Bay Online

Email ThisEmail Print ThisPrint AddThis Social Bookmark Button

TBO > News

Which Song Strikes State's Chord?

ADVERTISEMENT

Published: December 12, 2007

State Song Special Report

TAMPA - The proposal to retire a 150-year-old state song advanced to the Internet on Tuesday, opening the door to the possibility that Florida's anthem for a new era could be determined by the ultimate modern jury: voters in cyberspace.

The 243 entries vying to become the new state song were narrowed to three finalists, which were announced and posted on the Internet. To listen to the tunes, read the lyrics and vote for your favorite, go to www.justsingflorida.org.

Voting closes Jan. 11, and the winning song will be written into legislation for consideration next year.

Judges eschewed the jingly tunes that were submitted in favor of more stately, somber-sounding compositions appropriate for state ceremonies. The arrangements and some of the lyrics are reminiscent more of church hymns than the folk style of Florida's current song, "Old Folks at Home," widely known as "Swanee River."

"We are not erasing that song. We can always sing it as a memorable song about the way we were. But today, our state has changed so much," said Rep. Ed Homan, R-Tampa, who plans to file the House bill proposing a new song.

He was referring to the racial references in the old song, an ode to plantation life written by Stephen Foster in 1851.

"I invite everyone to go to the Web site and cast your vote, so when we present the bill, we can say, 'This is what the people of Florida choose to have as their state song,'" Homan said at a news conference to announce the finalists in the state Capitol in Tallahassee.

The finalists are:

•"Florida - Where the Sawgrass Meets the Sky" by Jan Hinton of Pompano Beach. Hinton, an elementary school music teacher who is a native of England, has lived in Florida 11 years. It took her a week to write the song, which lauds the "land of flowers, land of light ... where our dreams can all take flight."

•"Florida, My Home," music by Carl Ashley and lyrics by Betsy Dixon, both of Boynton Beach. The two met while singing in a Presbyterian church choir in Lake Worth. Their song mentions the "moonlight on the Suwannee River" and gives tribute to explorers who came here "reaching out for freedom's hand."

•"My Florida Home," by Christopher Marshall of Orlando. Marshall is a composer who was raised in New Zealand and has lived in Florida since last year. "Wherever I wander you shine in my mind," he wrote, inspired by the sights from his seat on a flight into Orlando. He penned the song before he knew a competition was in the works.

The songs sound nothing like the soulful track, "Florida's Song," submitted by local blues legend Charles Atkins. The song was a favorite of Gov. Charlie Crist, who tapped Atkins to play it at his inauguration this year.

Atkins, a native Floridian who runs a blues lab at Florida State University, said he was disappointed by the selections made by the six judges, most of whom are music educators.

"The songs sound sad to me," said Atkins, who described his song as more inspirational. He attended the news conference, along with a handful of other composers who had thrown their tunes into the competition.

The Rev. Abraham J. Thomas drove from Miami to hear the announcement after submitting two of his own songs for consideration. He called the contest a failure, because it selected songs that he considers detached from the average Floridian. Also, he said they sound alike.

"They're way over the top," he said, describing them as "not relatable to the everyday, common person."

Agile Communications Group of Tampa is running the site for free, after hearing about the push by Sen. Anthony Hill, D-Jacksonville, to find a new song. Technicians will try to prevent people from voting twice by requiring them to register phone numbers and e-mail addresses.

Those with multiple phones would be able to vote more than once, but Agile will validate the digits to prevent voters from entering phony ones, said Rick Bowen, chief operating officer.

The culmination of the search and the voting comes on Jan. 11, when the winner will be announced and performed by Tampa's King High School chorus at the Tampa Convention Center.

Photographer Colin Hackley contributed to this report. Reporter Gretchen Parker can be reached at (813) 259-7562 or gparker@tampatrib.com.

Reader Comments

Posted by ( germain863 ) on December 12, 2007 at 6:05 a.m. ( Suggest removal )

Just leave it alone. We can't change History for a few "whiners". If we are going this far, every song that isn't "politically correct" also has to be censored.

Report Inappropriate Comments

Posted by ( Major7th ) on December 12, 2007 at 1:48 p.m. ( Suggest removal )

I listened to the songs, including the Professors. His does sound the best, but he is right. If this is the best they have out of 243 entries, we're in sad shape. I would prefer keeping the original to accepting one of these. Did the judges listen to "I'm Florida" by Bobby Hicks. It's up beat Folk with a historic story of Florida, Imagine that, something with the focus their looking for. They need to put none of the above on their stupid ballot.

Report Inappropriate Comments

Posted by ( rocker419 ) on December 12, 2007 at 3:06 p.m. ( Suggest removal )

I listened to the three songs and they were obviously written by music teachers for music teachers. The judges should have known better but they got it wrong. My favorite? Go to www.sunshinestateofmind.net

Report Inappropriate Comments

Posted by ( sonvelmae ) on December 29, 2007 at 1:48 a.m. ( Suggest removal )

If it is decided for sure that the state song should be changed, I for one am very disappointed in the selections given for us to vote on. I agree with another person's comment. The three final songs were surely chosen by the music department staff with no consideration for the average person listening to or enjoy singing these songs. It seems to me that with the small amount of entries that were recieved, surely the final songs chosen for consideration could be selected possibly by a small citizens group somewhere in the state and maybe they could give the public a variety of 15 to 20 songs to select from. Personally I would like to see more variety. Something the average person could at least sing along with. I for one write alot of songs and poems and I enter a lot of contests and I have never seen anything like this where all the songs chosen sound so much alike.

Report Inappropriate Comments

Posted by ( pace ) on December 30, 2007 at 9:10 a.m. ( Suggest removal )

Keep Swanee River! It’s not over till the F.L. (Florida Legislature) sings. Keep the Modern Version of Swanee River.

Top Three Modern Versions

1. Vanilla Mood – International Swanee
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WgcX5leui3g&feature=user

2. Swanee River Boogie by Albert Ammons (1946) King of Boogie Woogie
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NtcPHr2yJ8A

3. Swanee River Rock by Fats Domino, Jerry Lee Lewis and Ray Charles
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x30b71_jerry-lee-lewisfats-and-friendsswan

2008 Concurrent Resolution to Keep Swanee River … the Modern Words
http://www.taxteaparty.com/resolution

Report Inappropriate Comments

Post a comment

(Requires free registration.)


* Keep it clean
* Respect others
* Don't hate
* Don't use language you wouldn't use with your mom
* Use "Report Inappropriate Comments" link when necessary
* See Member Agreement for details



User name:


Comment:


Email ThisEmail Print ThisPrint AddThis Social Bookmark Button
 

ADVERTISEMENT

Advertisement

IYP and SEO vendors: SEO by eLocalListing | Advertiser profiles