TBO.com - TBO is Tampa Bay Online

Digital Converter Boxes: Costliest Not Always The Best

Tribune photo by JIM REED

The setup of this Magnavox converter box was terribly complex, with no step-by-step process.

ADVERTISEMENT

By RICHARD MULLINS | The Tampa Tribune

Published: January 22, 2009

Woe be to TV fans who need to chose a digital converter box before the Feb.17 planned cutoff of analog TV.

After investigating whether their TV needs a converter box. After jumping through bureaucratic hoops to get a $40 coupon from the government to buy a box. After waiting for the coupon to arrive.

After all that, what box to pick? Some cost $40. Some cost almost $80. You might think the more expensive boxes perform better. Nope.

Digital broadcasting allows a station to send out multiple feeds. For example, WEDU sends four channels via digital and WFLA sends two.

We tested five converter boxes from the roughly 50 on the market. Some relatively inexpensive boxes were easy to use and pulled in every digital channel available. Other pricey models couldn't pull in some major network broadcasts.

Some boxes could show PBS on the north side of our test house, but not the south. Vice versa with other boxes and NBC. Many had horrible static on the screen, or just wouldn't show many channels at all.

Some boxes were terribly difficult to use. That is, unless you recognize what the "EPG" button on the remote control means (we're not really sure), or you think this on-screen instruction makes sense: "Connect ST band TV via RF cable."

One box didn't even have volume buttons on the remote control, which means you'd change channels with your old remote control, but change volume with another.

To help TV fans pick a good DTV box, here is Tampa's first ever real-life review of DTV boxes, taken from testing actual TV stations here in Tampa Bay.

Magnavox TT110MW9

Price: $49

Available: Wal-Mart.

Verdict: Worst performing box in our group.

The setup was terribly complex, with no step-by-step process. There are no volume buttons on the remote control, which means you need to change channels with the converter box remote but raise or lower the volume with your old TV remote. It also took several seconds to change channels.

In a North-facing room, WEDU's channels didn't appear. In a South-facing room, they did, but other networks didn't appear, including the WFLA channels. (One is the NBC affiliate; the other is 8 Prime, which carries reruns of vintage programs.)

Insignia NS-DXA1-APT

Note: BestBuy's private label brand.

Price: $59.99

Available: BestBuy.

Verdict: One of the best in the group.

Simple and easy setup out of the box, with step-by-step process. Clear graphics for on-screen information about each program. Handy "zoom" button can adjust size of TV image, which differs among digital TV broadcasters and shows.

Clearly received all major TV networks in both north and south of our test house with only occasional static.

Channel Master

Note: Received best-picture quality rating from Consumer Reports.

Price:$48.69

Available: Select stores and SolidSignal.com.

Verdict: Clear picture, unable to bring in many channels.

Clear image, but with some drawbacks. Setup was somewhat complex. Did not restart well after unplugging to change TVs. Mute button did not work while showing program information on screen.

GE 23333

Price: $69.99

Available: Many stores and online.

Verdict: Poor reception, missing significant channels.

Despite an appealing wave design on the box, the GE model had mixed performance. Setup was fairly easy, and it has a large and clear program information guide, with information about shows through the day and week. Subtitles were quite easy to turn on/off. Suggestive "Applications" item on setup menu suggests room for new digital services to come. However, it only picked up WEDU stations in north room of house. Only picked up WFLA (NBC) in the south room.

Zenith DTT901

Note: Made by the same manufacturer as the Insignia. Available in more retail locations.

Price: $59.95

Available: Kmart, Sears, Circuit City during its liquidation.

Verdict: One of the best in group.

Clearly received all major TV networks in both north and south of our test house with only occasional static. Again, we enjoyed the simple setup, clear graphics, information about programs and "zoom" button to show programs properly.

Reporter Richard Mullins can be reached at (813) 259-7919.

Share this:

Loading Comments...

Email Print

ADVERTISEMENT